One margin account at Asia Pacific Securities JSC (APEC Securities, ticker APS on HNX) carried a loan balance above 3% of the firm's equity on all four reporting dates between 31 December 2024 and 30 September 2026.Tin nhanh Chứng khoán It is one of five violations listed by the State Securities Inspectorate in Decision No. 690/QĐ-XPHC of 12 November 2026, which carries total fines of VND 692.5 million. The decision took effect on the day it was signed.Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam
The fine is small for a brokerage. What deserves attention is that the five violations cluster around two questions: where the firm's own capital is placed, and who receives its margin loans. The remaining violation touches the client side, in the paperwork for the account that holds clients' trading deposits. If limits like these stay breached for long, the risk lands first on shareholders, then on clients using the firm's services.
Five violations and their fines
According to the decision as reported in the press, APS was fined for the following:
- Breaching investment limits: unlisted shares were 27% of equity at 30 June 2026 and 28.53% at 30 September 2026, above the 20% maximum. Fine: VND 137.5 million.Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam
- Using staff without a securities practice certificate to sign for the Proprietary Trading Department on two submissions seeking approval of proprietary trading plans, dated 8 June 2026 and 20 July 2026. Fine: VND 137.5 million.Tin nhanh Chứng khoán
- Failing to keep complete records: the firm could not produce the contracts opening dedicated accounts at commercial banks to receive clients' securities-trading deposits. Fine: VND 92.5 million.Người Đưa Tin
- Breaching the margin lending limit: total margin lending to the client holding account 030C016804 exceeded 3% of equity at 31 December 2024, 31 December 2025, 30 June 2026 and 30 September 2026. Fine: VND 137.5 million.Người Đưa Tin
- Breaching lending restrictions: between 18 March and 19 August 2026 the firm lent its chief accountant money for margin trading 12 times, VND 64.46 million in total. Fine: VND 187.5 million, the highest of the five.FireAnt

The highest fine landed on the smallest amount. The decision classes this loan as a breach of lending restrictions, where the borrower was the chief accountant, the person who keeps the firm's own books.
First place: the firm's capital in hard-to-sell assets
Under Article 28 of Circular 121/2020/TT-BTC, a securities firm may not invest more than 20% of its equity in unlisted shares, capital contributions and business projects. Unlisted shares have no public daily price and are hard to sell quickly when the firm needs cash. The cap keeps most of a firm's equity in assets that can be turned into cash.
At APS the ratio was 27% at the end of June and 28.53% at the end of September.Tin nhanh Chứng khoán The excess over the cap widened from 7 to 8.53 percentage points in a single quarter.

The ratio rose in the same quarter the firm posted a loss. In Q3 APS lost VND 42.6 billion after tax,Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam and the loss shrinks equity. If the investment stayed unchanged, the smaller denominator alone would push the ratio up; if the firm bought more unlisted shares, the ratio would climb faster still. Either way the consequence for shareholders is the same: a larger share of capital sits in hard-to-sell assets just as equity is falling.
The second violation also sits in the proprietary trading business. Two submissions seeking approval of proprietary trading plans, in June and July, were signed for the Proprietary Trading Department by a staff member without a practice certificate. The certificate is what ensures that the person proposing how to deploy the firm's capital understands the rules and answers for the proposal.
Second place: where the margin money goes
Under margin trading rules, a securities firm's total lending to one client may not exceed 3% of the firm's equity.Thời báo Tài chính The limit stops one client from taking too large a share of the lending capital. If that client cannot repay, or the pledged shares fall sharply and cannot be sold, the loss concentrates in one place.
At APS, account 030C016804 breached the limit on all four reporting dates, the earliest being 31 December 2024. The four dates span more than 21 months. This is not a brief breach during a volatile session but a condition that recurs at year-end, mid-year and quarter-end closings.
The margin loans to the chief accountant fall under a separate violation. The VND 64.46 million over 12 loans is small next to the firm's size, yet the decision fines it VND 187.5 million, the highest of the five. For anyone borrowing on margin at any brokerage, the takeaway is that lending limits are set by the firm's equity, not by a client's demand.
The client side: records for the deposit account
The VND 92.5 million fine is for failing to produce the contracts opening dedicated accounts at commercial banks to receive clients' securities-trading deposits. The decision places this under failure to keep complete records and documents.Tin nhanh Chứng khoán It is a paperwork breach, not a finding that clients' money was misused.
Even so, the dedicated-account contract is the document that shows which bank holds a client's trading deposit. A client of any brokerage can ask the firm which bank hosts the dedicated account receiving their money, then compare the balance in the app with periodic statements.
Third-quarter results
In Q3 2026, APS's operating revenue was VND 9.7 billion, down 90.1% from VND 98.7 billion a year earlier. Gains on financial assets at fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL) fell to VND 4.84 billion from VND 91.4 billion in Q3 2025. Losses on those assets rose from VND 37 billion to VND 55.9 billion.Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam
The firm lost VND 42.6 billion after tax in Q3, against a profit of VND 43.5 billion a year earlier. For the first nine months, APS lost VND 19.35 billion.Người Đưa Tin

APS explained that volatile financial markets pushed down the market value of the financial assets it holds.Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam The revaluation loss on FVTPL assets in the quarter was VND 54.98 billion.Người Đưa Tin Of Q3 operating revenue, FVTPL gains were VND 4.84 billion out of VND 9.7 billion; a year earlier they were VND 91.4 billion out of VND 98.7 billion.
HNX placed APS shares on its warning list in April 2026 because retained after-tax profit at 31 December 2025 was negative and the auditor gave a qualified opinion on the 2023 and 2024 financial statements.Doanh Nghiệp Việt Nam The stock closed at VND 4,300 on 16 November.

Who carries the risk when limits are breached
The 20% and 3% equity limits serve one purpose: keeping a securities firm's capital from piling into hard-to-sell assets or into a single client. When they are breached and stay breached, the risk falls first on shareholders, because every loss from an illiquid portfolio or a large loan comes straight out of equity. Clients using the service come next, since equity is also the base on which the firm extends margin limits and meets financial-safety ratios.
For anyone holding APS shares, the main point from the decision is that the share of unlisted shares in equity rose in a quarter when the firm lost money. For clients who borrow on margin or keep trading deposits at APS, the decision shows that limit-setting for a single client and record-keeping for the deposit account are where inspectors found violations.
The next markers are APS's Q4 2026 financial statements and its next financial-safety ratio report: they will show whether unlisted shares have fallen back below 20% of equity. If equity keeps shrinking on losses, the ratio will be hard to bring down even if the firm buys nothing more.

